3.6 Three-Gate Evaluation Framework
How to decide what to automate next
What this is
Before building any new automation, every idea gets evaluated against three gates. This prevents building automations that nobody uses or that don't produce measurable output. The core principle: the metric is never time saved. It is always output multiplied.
Gate 1 — Capacity (non-negotiable)
|
Question |
Does this remove work from an architect so they can manage more clients — or improve the architect's ability to have meaningful conversations with clients? |
G1 is non-negotiable. If an automation does not pass G1, it stops here. This is the only gate that can block an idea entirely.
Gate 2 — Retention
|
Question |
Does this protect client health — through better meeting hygiene, proactive conversations, or improving the client's experience of working with RevGravy? |
G2 adds weight toward BUILD NOW. G1 + G2 = strong candidate.
Gate 3 — Compounding Value
|
Question |
Does this get more valuable over time, or does it enable other automations to work better? |
G3 pushes BUILD NOW to top priority. Infrastructure automations often pass G3 because future systems depend on them.
Scoring and verdict
|
Gates passed |
Verdict |
Action |
|
G1 only |
BUILD NEXT |
Queue for the following cycle |
|
G1 + G2 |
BUILD NOW |
Add to current or next cycle as priority build |
|
G1 + G2 + G3 |
BUILD NOW (top priority) |
Anchor build for next cycle — start here |
|
No G1 |
DEFER |
Do not build regardless of G2/G3 |
How to run an evaluation
- Write the idea in one sentence: 'When X happens, automatically do Y, resulting in Z'
- Run it through G1: does Z remove architect work or improve architect conversations?
- Run it through G2: does Z improve client experience or health?
- Run it through G3: does Z create compounding value or enable other systems?
- Record the verdict in the Automation Catalog (Google Sheet)
- Bring BUILD NOW candidates to Phil in the next cycle planning meeting
|
Core principle |
The metric is never time saved. It is always output multiplied. An automation that saves 30 minutes but doesn't increase client capacity or output quality has not earned its place. |